The guide · 3 min read
Subscription documents are where a fund close actually happens. Each investor completes a subscription agreement and investor questionnaire, signs the signature pages, and returns tax forms and KYC materials. Until each package is complete and accepted by the GP, that investor is not admitted and their commitment cannot be counted at closing.
The five signs below are the common reasons a close slips even when the LPA is final and the commitments are verbal. Check each one against the subscription process you are running now.
Investors fill them out as flat PDFs
A flat PDF lets an investor skip required fields, check two boxes that cannot both be true, or sign the wrong page. You only find out when someone reads the returned document line by line, and every error sends the package back to the investor for a corrected page.
Check whether your sub docs have required fields, conditional sections (for example, entity questions that only apply to trusts or funds of funds), and a single signature flow. If they do not, plan for a manual completeness review on every package and budget time for it.
Accreditation answers are inconsistent
The questionnaire asks investors to confirm their status, commonly accredited investor status under Regulation D and, for a 3(c)(7) fund, qualified purchaser status. Investors sometimes pick a category that does not match the entity type they listed, or claim qualified purchaser status in one section and leave the supporting answers blank.
Compare the status answers against the investor's entity type, formation documents, and KYC file before you accept the subscription. Resolve inconsistencies in writing, because the GP is relying on these representations to keep the offering within its exemption.
Tax forms come back missing pages
A Form W-9 is short, but a Form W-8BEN-E for a foreign entity investor is long and easy to complete partially. A missing certification page or an unchecked treaty or status box can leave the fund unable to rely on the form for withholding purposes.
Review tax forms for completeness at the same time as the questionnaire, and keep a list of which form each investor owes based on their status.
Nobody reviews them until the week of close
When packages sit unread in an inbox, every problem surfaces at once in the final days. Investors are then chasing corrected pages while the GP is also finalizing side letters and wire instructions.
Review each package within a day or two of receipt and log its status: received, deficient, cured, accepted. With a running log, the closing week is spent confirming packages that were already reviewed.
Each LP's counsel marks up a different version
Institutional investors often send the subscription agreement to their own counsel. If different investors are working from different drafts, you end up reconciling markups against versions that no longer exist.
Circulate one final version, mark it clearly with a date or version number, and decline markups to the subscription agreement itself where you can. Negotiated points usually belong in a side letter, which keeps the subscription agreement uniform across investors.
What to do this week
A few concrete steps will show you how exposed your close is.
- Pull every returned subscription package and log its status in one place.
- Check accreditation and qualified purchaser answers against each investor's entity type.
- List the tax form each investor owes and flag any that came back incomplete.
- Confirm every investor and their counsel has the same final version of the sub docs.
- Set a cutoff date for complete packages that falls well before the closing date.
Questions
Can an investor be admitted with an incomplete subscription package?+
That depends on your LPA and subscription agreement, which usually let the GP accept or reject subscriptions in its discretion. In practice, accepting an incomplete package means relying on representations you have not confirmed, so most GPs cure deficiencies before admission. Check what your documents allow and what your administrator needs before it records the investor.
Should LP side letter requests be handled in the subscription agreement?+
Generally no. Keeping the subscription agreement uniform makes review faster and keeps investors on the same terms. Investor specific requests, such as reporting, fee arrangements, or tax accommodations, are usually documented in a side letter, which is then tracked for MFN purposes.
Further reading
This guide is general information about how private funds commonly handle this work. It is not legal advice; check your own fund documents with counsel.
