The guide · 3 min read
Emerging managers often settle fund terms quickly, borrowing from a precedent or a peer's documents. Some of those terms carry consequences that only show up years later: in a key person event, a clawback, or the first distribution under the waterfall.
The five signs below are reasons to have counsel walk through your terms again before the documents are final.
You copied the fee terms from a larger fund
A management fee sized for a large fund may not cover a smaller fund's costs, or may look out of line to investors in a smaller fund. Fee base, step-down, and offset terms also depend on fund size and strategy.
Model your management fee income against your actual operating budget for the life of the fund. Include the years after any step-down, when fee income usually falls while portfolio work continues.
Your key person clause names one person
If the key person clause names one person, any departure or reduced involvement by that person can trigger the clause, often suspending the investment period. That may be appropriate, but it should be a deliberate decision.
Check who is named, what time commitment is required, and what happens when the clause is triggered.
The GP commitment is unclear
Investors expect the GP to commit its own capital to the fund. The LPA should state how much, whether it can be funded through fee waivers, and who among the GP's principals funds it.
Confirm the commitment amount and how it will be funded are clear in the LPA. If fee waivers are used, check that the tax treatment has been reviewed by your adviser.
Clawback terms were never modeled
A GP clawback requires the GP to return carried interest it received in excess of what it was entitled to over the life of the fund. Terms such as whether the clawback is net of taxes, and whether principals give guarantees, determine how much the GP's principals may owe personally.
Ask counsel or your fund accountant to model a scenario where early distributions are followed by losses.
Nobody walked you through the waterfall
The distribution waterfall determines how proceeds are split between LPs and the GP: return of capital, preferred return, catch-up, and carried interest, applied either deal by deal or on a whole of fund basis.
Ask counsel to walk through a sample distribution step by step using your actual terms. Use realistic numbers, including a case with one early exit and one later loss, so you can see when carry is paid and when it could be clawed back.
What to do this week
These steps take a few hours with counsel.
- Model management fee income against your operating budget.
- Review who is named in the key person clause and what triggers it.
- Confirm the GP commitment amount and funding method.
- Ask for a clawback scenario and a waterfall walkthrough.
Questions
What is a GP clawback?+
A clawback requires the GP to return carried interest it received during the life of the fund if, at the end, it received more than its share under the waterfall. Clawbacks are often calculated net of taxes paid on that carry, and investors may ask the GP's principals to guarantee them.
What is the difference between a European and an American waterfall?+
A European, or whole of fund, waterfall pays carried interest only after LPs have received their contributed capital and preferred return across the fund. An American, or deal by deal, waterfall can pay carry on individual investments earlier, which makes clawback terms more important.
Further reading
This guide is general information about how private funds commonly handle this work. It is not legal advice; check your own fund documents with counsel.
